Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland

Reformed in Doctrine, Worship, and Practice

“Thou hast given a banner to them that fear thee, that it may be displayed because of the truth.” Psalm 60:4

  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Who We Are
    • What We Contend For
    • What We Believe
    • How We Worship
    • How We Are Organised
    • Important Documents
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Articles
  • Publications
    • Free Presbyterian Magazine
    • Young People’s Magazine
    • Gaelic Supplement – An Earrann Ghàidhlig
    • Synod Reports
    • Religion and Morals Committee Reports
  • Audio
    • Sermons
    • Theological Conferences
    • Youth Conferences
  • Congregations
    • Places of Worship
    • Current Ministers
    • Galleries of FP Churches
  • International
    • Zimbabwe Mission
    • Other International Congregations
    • Translation Work
    • Metrical Psalms in Various Languages
  • History
    • History of the FP Church
    • Congregational Histories
    • Deceased Ministers and Probationers
    • Obituaries and Synod Tributes
    • Moderators of Synod etc.
  • Spiritual Help
    • How to Find Spiritual Help
    • How may a sinner be saved?
    • How may someone know if they are truly saved?
    • Spiritual Mindedness
    • Scripture and Catechism Exercises 2020-21
  • Bookshop
Home / About Us / Who We Are / The Declaratory Act Controversy / Declaratory Act – Reasons for Separation

Declaratory Act – Reasons for Separation

[This article was published in the first issue of the Free Presbyterian Magazine in May 1896.]

At a time when the religious world abounds with periodicals it may seem superfluous to add another to their number. But seeing the majority of these are, as we think, conducted in the interests of a bad or defective theology, we trust our intention to recruit the ranks of sound periodic literature will seem justifiable. Our Magazine, as its name indicates, is published specially in the interests of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland, and, in presenting our first number, we think it proper to state briefly the reasons we had for our separation from the present Free Church, and the principles and doctrines for which we are especially called upon to contend.

1. General declension from the doctrines of divine truth.

The first reason we give for our separation from the above Church, is her general declension from the doctrines of divine truth. No one that is acquainted with the history of the Free Church since the Disruption of 1843 can fail to observe that a great change has crept over her. In 1843 she stood forth as one of the pillars of evangelical orthodoxy, and as a willing martyr for the doctrine of Christ’s Headship over church and nation. The teaching of her pulpits and the deliverances of her Assemblies were then in harmony with the principles of the Westminster Confession of Faith, whose whole doctrine she had sworn to defend. A considerable religious revival had preceded the Disruption, and when this event took place (an event which involved not a little self-sacrifice on the part of those who left the Establishment), many thought the millennium was about to dawn.

But these fair anticipations were doomed to disappointment. For the greater part of the 53 years that have elapsed since then, her history has been one of declension and departure from her original position and standards.

  • So early as 1852, the Rev. Jonathan R. Anderson, Glasgow, withdrew from her Communion for this, among other reasons, that Arminianism was tolerated in some of her pulpits.
  • Not many years thereafter negotiations were entered into for union with the U.P. Church, a step that involved surrender of some very important doctrines of truth, and one that was only frustrated by the strong opposition of the conservative section in the Church. The latter threatened they would separate if union with the U.P. body would take place. The willingness to make open questions of important doctrines at that time has produced its fruits in the subsequent history of the Free Church.
  • The use of hymns and instrumental music in the worship of God has been allowed and widely practised within her pale for a number of years. The purity of New Testament worship is thus corrupted, and the presence and blessing of the Holy Spirit in the worship of God largely, if not wholly, lost.
  • The Church also of late years, through majorities of her General Assemblies, has repeatedly passed resolutions in favour of the separation of Church and State, and, as a body, has practically abandoned her own testimony to the doctrine of the national establishment of religion. These resolutions are clearly subversive of the great truth that Christ is King of nations, and that nations, as such, are bound to recognise and support His Church.
  • The declension and fall of the Free Church is also clearly marked out in the toleration she has extended to dangerous errors preached and published by ministers and leading professors in her Divinity Halls. In 1888, Dr. Marcus Dods affirmed in a paper read before the Pan-Presbyterian Council, met in London, that there were “errors, inaccuracies, and immoralities” in the Holy Scriptures. Instead of being asked by the Assembly to withdraw and renounce this unwarrantable and pernicious error, he was shortly after chosen to be Professor of New Testament Exegesis in the New College, Edinburgh. Instead of receiving excommunication, he was exalted to one of the highest positions the Church could give, and has been at full liberty ever since to teach his erroneous views of truth to the prospective ministers of the Church. He was not long a professor when he announced in a sermon on “What is a Christian?” preached in St. Giles, Edinburgh, the startling view that a man may be a true Christian and not believe in the divinity of Christ. A mild caution from the Assembly was the only discipline for this serious dishonour to Christ and injury to the souls of men. Nothing was done to prevent the further propagation of similar errors. Professor A. B. Bruce, Glasgow, also in his book on the Kingdom of God charged the writers of the Gospels with imperfect narration. Luke was said to have toned down some of the severe expressions that fell from the lips of the Lord Jesus. Here was an impeachment of the infallibility of the Word of God of which the Holy Ghost is author. Dr. Bruce, also, attributed imperfect knowledge to Christ. The whole tone and tendency of the book was rationalistic, and instead of being adapted to convince gainsayers, was fitted to strengthen such in their infidel notions. Dr. Bruce, however, got off with a slight censure by the General Assembly.

These are cases in brief in which the Free Church failed to bear testimony to doctrines that lie at the foundation of the Christian faith. She has delighted to honour men who have cast aside the Bible as the Word of God, and who treat it as a common book. In a word, she has become known throughout the world as the pioneer of heresy, and has earned the unenviable distinction of being foremost in undermining the foundation truths of the Gospel. The continued course of defection pursued by this once sound Church grieved the minds of many within her pale and caused questions of duty to arise.

2. Passing the Declaratory Act.

At length, however, the crisis came when the case for separation seemed no longer doubtful. In 1892 the Church passed the Declaratory Act. This Act is the formal reason of our separation. Departures, innovations, and errors prevailed on all hands, but it seemed the duty of the ministry, so long as the constitution was intact, to remain in the Church, and to protest by every means in their power against the prevalent declension. When, however, the Church, through a majority of her Presbyteries, and by the vote of the Assembly in 1892, passed the Declaratory Act, we felt that now not only the innovating majority, but all who remained in their fellowship would be involved by this Act in the guilt of past and present declensions.

  • This Act was drawn up for the purpose of affording legal scope within the Church to those who were not prepared to accept the whole doctrine of the Confession of Faith. It cast the shield of its protection over men of erroneous views already within her fold, and opened a wide door for others like-minded who chose to enter.
  • The Act professes to be an exposition of doctrines contained in the Confession of Faith, and also to indicate what views of truth may be held consistently with the maintenance of the Confession. This profession, we believe, is entirely misleading, for the doctrines of the Declaratory Act are not only not in the Confession, nor are consistent therewith, but are clearly subversive of its teaching.
  • Such doctrines as those of eternal election, the imputation of Adam’s guilt to his posterity, the total depravity of man, the necessity of the almighty irresistible grace of the Holy Ghost in regeneration, and the absolute need of the declaration of the Gospel for the salvation of sinners among all nations, are virtually denied.
  • It is also, by implication, asserted in this Act that the doctrine of national establishments of religion involves intolerant and persecuting principles.
  • And lastly, the closing section of the Act declares that certain points of doctrine in the Confession do not enter into the substance of the Reformed Faith, that diversity of opinion is recognised on these points, and that the Church reserves the right to determine what these points are. The infallibility of the Scriptures is evidently one of these points, as we learn by the decisions of the General Assembly in cases already mentioned, and therefore diversity of opinion is recognised in the Church in this fundamental doctrine.
  • The Confession of Faith has been set aside as the chief subordinate standard, and “the substance of the Reformed Faith therein set forth” is substituted in its place. The fixed doctrinal constitution of the Church has thus been overthrown, and the creed lies at “the feet of an irresponsible majority to determine the same as it will”. In a word, the Church has set itself not only above the Confession of Faith, but it has assumed a daring authority over the very Word of God, and takes the place of the latter as the supreme arbiter of appeal. This is the essence of Popery.
  • We, in fact, find in the Declaratory Act errors of Arminianism, Pelagianism, Voluntaryism, and Romanism. We are commanded by the Word of God to “Have no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness”, and therefore we cannot have fellowship with a Church that adopts these errors as part of her creed and testimony.

We are told by many in the Church that the Declaratory Act is a dead letter because they do not approve of it. But such persons must remember that the Act received the sanction of the Church Courts in regular form, and is now a standing law and constitution in the Church. If they are not personally compelled to accept it, the Church, of which they are a component part, has already accepted it. All past protests against the Act have been declared null and void by the Church, and no office-bearer can prevent his neighbour from accepting all the doctrines of the Declaratory Act. The private opinion of individuals is utterly useless to prevent the full operation of the Act.

The Church of 1843 has no existence so far as the present Free Church is concerned. It is the Church that has adopted the Declaratory Act that now lives, and it is this Church we have felt constrained to separate from. As the Free Presbyterian Church our profession and confession are none other than those of the Church of Scotland from the beginning. We contend for all the principles of the Free Church as settled in 1843, and are, we believe, the true Free Church of Scotland.

The addition of the word Presbyterian does not indicate any change in our attitude or principles as a Church. It serves, however, two purposes. It distinguishes us from the present Church calling herself Free, with which we might have justly contested the title, and it emphasises the fact that it was in consistently adhering to the principles of Presbyterianism that we were compelled to set up a separate jurisdiction.

3. Principles now to be contended for.

The following is a brief summary of the principles which we are called upon to emphasise at the present time:

  1. The perpetual obligation upon nations, and our nation in particular, to recognise, support, and defend the Church of Christ, Presbyterian in doctrine, worship, and discipline;
  2. The use of the Book of Psalms only as to the matter of praise in the worship of God; and as to the manner thereof, singing with the human voice to the exclusion of instrumental music; and
  3. The whole doctrine of the Confession of Faith as it relates to the infallibility, inspiration, and authority of the Holy Scriptures, the decrees of God, the atonement, man’s total depravity, the work of the Holy Spirit, and the preaching of the Gospel.

In conclusion, we remark that this magazine will exist for the maintenance of these doctrines, and for bearing testimony against the erroneous tendencies of the times in which we live. We shall endeavour to combine with the magazine, a record of events among our own congregations, and also brief notices of current events of special religious interest taking place in Church and State. Our readers will excuse deficiencies in this number as it is our first. Above all other things, we would ask for the prayers and sympathy of all who fear the name of the Lord, that the magazine may, by His blessing, be an agent for spiritual good, and may prove helpful in advancing the cause of the Lord in our land and generation.

Previous / Next

About Us

  • Who We Are
    • The Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland – Why It Exists Today
    • The Free Presbyterian Church Catechism
      • A Catechism of the History and Principles of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland – PDF
      • 1. Origins of the Free Presbyterian Church (1-13)
      • 2. The Westminster Confession of Faith (14–22)
      • 3. The Declaratory Act and the Free Church (23–53)
      • 4. The Infallibility of Scripture (54-67)
      • 5. Erroneous Doctrines (68-77)
      • 6. Innovations in Worship (78-93)
      • 7. Church and State (94-104)
      • 8. Church office-bearers (105-130)
      • 9. Church Courts (131-140)
      • 10. Church Unity (141-149)
      • 11. Modern Religious Cults (150-159)
      • 12. Modern Errors (160-170)
      • 13. Evolution (171-175)
      • 14. Christ’s Second Coming (176-179)
      • Appendix 1. Deed of Separation 1893
      • Appendix 2. Free Church of Scotland Declaratory Act 1892
      • Appendix 3. FP Synod Resolutions
      • Appendix 4. Questions put to Office-bearers and Formula to be signed by them
      • Appendix 5. Memorandum on the Church of Scotland Enabling Bill 1920
    • The Declaratory Act Controversy
      • Declaratory Act – Reasons for Separation
      • How the Declaratory Act changed the Constitution of the Free Church
      • Explanatory Criticism of the Declaratory Act
      • The Consequences of the Declaratory Act
      • The Declaratory Act and Admission into Office in the Free Church
      • The Constitutional Aspects of the Declaratory Act
      • A Brief History of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland
  • What We Contend For
    • Our Free Presbyterian Heritage
    • The Authorised Version
      • The Importance of the Authorised Version for the Church in Britain
      • 2015 Synod Resolution on Versions of the Bible
    • Evangelical or Reformed
    • A Protestant Witness
      • The Pope and the Constitution of the United Kingdom
      • The Pope as the Head of a False Religion
      • Papal Infallibility
      • The Pope in Scripture
    • The Five Points of Calvinism
      • The Canons of Dort
    • The Free Offer of the Gospel
    • Resolution on Creed Subscription
    • Church Discipline
      • The Purposes of Church Discipline
      • The Church’s responsibility to administer Biblical discipline faithfully
      • The benefits of exercising Church discipline
      • Accusations Levelled against a Church Exercising Discipline
    • Baptism
      • Subjects of Baptism – by Rev. William MacIntyre
      • Mode of Baptism – by Rev. William Macintyre
      • Should Infants be Baptised?
    • The Lord’s Supper
      • Why do the minister and elders interview intending communicants?
      • Restricted Communion
      • Fencing the Table
        • The Origins of Fencing the Table
    • Our Separate Stance
    • The Sabbath
      • Why the Sabbath should Still be Kept
      • How the Sabbath should be Kept
      • Sabbath or Lord’s Day – not “Sunday”
      • What about using Public Transport on the Sabbath?
        • Synod’s Statement in Reference to Church-going by Public Conveyances on the Sabbath
        • Historical Controversy over Using Public Transport on the Lord’s Day
    • Family worship
      • Family worship – a recent overview
      • Family worship – a recent address to young people
      • Family worship – a convicting appeal from C H Spurgeon
      • Family worship – a wartime appeal from more than a century ago
      • Family worship – a review
      • Family worship – another wartime appeal
      • Family worship – an illustration of its power
    • Distinctions between Male and Female
      • Men and Women Equal in Value
      • The Distinct Roles of Men and Women
      • Can women lead in public prayer?
      • Distinct Clothing for Men and Women
      • Long hair for women and short hair for men
        • If a Woman have Long Hair, it is a Glory to Her
  • What We Believe
  • How We Worship
    • Order of Service
    • The Right Way to Worship
      • Standing for Prayer
      • The Charismatic Movement – The Gifts have Ceased
    • The Regulative Principle of Worship
      • Does the Bible tell us how we are to Worship?
      • The Importance of the Regulative Principle for Today
      • The Regulative Principle as defined by the Scottish Reformers and others
    • Exclusive Psalmody
      • Does the Bible tell us What to Sing?
      • Why Psalms Only
    • No Musical Instruments
      • Musical Instruments in Worship
    • No Christian “Festivals”
      • Should Christians Celebrate Christmas?
  • How We Are Organised
    • Church Courts
    • Scripture does teach the right form of Church Government
    • The Apostolic Church – Which Is It?
      • Statement of the Question
      • Meaning of the word Church
      • Government of the Church
      • Apostolic Principles
      • The First Principle
      • The Second Principle
      • The Third Principle
      • The Fourth Principle
      • The Fifth Principle
      • The Sixth Principle
      • Application of the Test
      • Application of the Test to Prelacy
      • Application of the Test to Independency
      • Application of the Test to Presbytery
      • Application of the Test – Result
  • Important Documents
    • The Scots Confession
    • The First Book of Discipline
    • The Second Book of Discipline
    • The National Covenant
    • The Solemn League and Covenant
    • The Westminster Confession of Faith
    • The Larger Catechism
    • The Shorter Catechism
    • The Directory for Public Worship
    • The Form of Presbyterial Church Government
    • The Sum of Saving Knowledge
    • The Directory for Family Worship
    • The Claim Declaration and Protest
    • The Protest
    • The Deed of Separation 1893
  • Frequently Asked Questions

Calendar

  1. 29 Jan - Meeting of Presbytery: Asia Pacific
  2. 24 Feb - Meeting of Presbytery: Southern
  3. 9 Mar - Meeting of Presbyteries: Western and Northern

View All Events

Latest Articles

  • Approaching Judgments – Part 2
  • The Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland
  • Approaching Judgments – Part 1

Recently Added Audio

  • Direction for Joshua 4 Oct 2020
  • God pleased to use preaching 4 Oct 2020
  • Enduring by faith 27 Dec 2020
  • I was brought low 3 Jan 2021
  • Jesus in the midst 3 Jan 2021
  • The Father calling sinners to Christ 22 Nov 2020
  • The Day of Salvation 27 Dec 2020
  • Jesus standing still 8 Nov 2020
  • Then cometh the end 27 Dec 2020
  • Christ will still build His Church 10 Jan 2021

View All Sermons

Download Latest Issues:
The Free Presbyterian Magazine
Young People’s Magazine

Free Presbyterian Places of Worship

Browse the Church Bookshop

Solitude Improved by Divine Meditation by Nathanael Ranew, £11.99
The Priesthood of Christ by Peter MacBride, £6.36
None Other Name: Daily Devotional Readings by 19th Century Scottish Ministers compiled by L J van Valen, £11.79
Thoughts on Religious Experience by Archibald Alexander, £12.49
William Farel by Frances Bevan,  £12.49

Back to top

Website Contact

Rev Keith M Watkins
[email protected]

Moderator of Synod

Rev J Bruce Jardine
FP Manse, Tarbert
Isle of Harris, HS3 3DF
UK

Clerk of Synod

Rev Keith M Watkins
Free Presbyterian Manse, Ferry Road, Leverburgh, Isle of Harris, HS5 3UA, UK.
[email protected]

General Treasurer

Mr William Campbell
133 Woodlands Road, Glasgow,
G3 6LE, UK.
[email protected]

Copyright © 2021 Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland · Log in · Subscribe via RSS · Privacy Notice

This site uses cookies to improve your experience. Read more.