Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland

Reformed in Doctrine, Worship, and Practice

“Thou hast given a banner to them that fear thee, that it may be displayed because of the truth.” Psalm 60:4

  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Who We Are
    • What We Contend For
    • What We Believe
    • How We Worship
    • How We Are Organised
    • Important Documents
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Articles
  • Publications
    • Free Presbyterian Magazine
    • Young People’s Magazine
    • Gaelic Supplement – An Earrann Ghàidhlig
    • Synod Reports
    • Religion and Morals Committee Reports
  • Audio
    • Sermons
    • Theological Conferences
    • Youth Conferences
  • Congregations
    • Places of Worship
    • Current Ministers
    • Galleries of FP Churches
  • International
    • Zimbabwe Mission
    • Other International Congregations
    • Translation Work
    • Metrical Psalms in Various Languages
  • History
    • History of the FP Church
    • Congregational Histories
    • Deceased Ministers and Probationers
    • Obituaries and Synod Tributes
    • Moderators of Synod etc.
  • Spiritual Help
    • How to Find Spiritual Help
    • How may a sinner be saved?
    • How may someone know if they are truly saved?
    • Spiritual Mindedness
    • Scripture and Catechism Exercises 2021-22
  • Bookshop
Home / About Us / Who We Are / The Declaratory Act Controversy / The Consequences of the Declaratory Act

The Consequences of the Declaratory Act

We intend in this article to state several consequences, some of which have been already alluded to, that have flowed from the passing of the Declaratory Act into law by the courts of the Free Church.

1. The constitution of the Church has been essentially changed.

Formerly the Confession of Faith was accepted by all without reservation or modification. Now, the Declaratory Act sets forth the Church’s modified relation to the doctrines of the Confession. This has revealed serious changes in the Church’s doctrinal beliefs. In fact the Church in this Act declares itself in favour of doctrines that are quite inconsistent with, and opposed to the doctrines of the Confession. If the constitution of a Church is embodied in its standard documents, then the constitution is essentially changed when a new document, such as this Declaratory Act is added, whereby the statements of its former documents are explained away or misinterpreted, and new statements of an inconsistent or contrary character are affirmed.

2. The Declaratory Act has now become, to all intents and purposes, the creed of the Free Church.

The Confession has been set aside, and the views of all parties are now measured by the standard set up in this Act. If they come up to this standard nothing more is expected of them. All cases of heresy or discipline will therefore be tried by this test, and not simply by the Confession of Faith.

3. The Declaratory Act, in the last clause thereof, affirms that it is only “the substance of the Reformed Faith” set forth in the Confession that is to be held fast in the Church.

“Diversity of opinion is recognised” on all points that do not touch this substance. There is no hiding here of a change of creed, however this change may be denied from pulpit or platform. “The substance of the Faith” is not defined, and therefore views of the most dangerous character may be declared as not touching the substance.

4. The Church, or in other words, the General Assembly, by the same clause has been declared to be the final judge as to what is the substance of the faith.

This leaves the whole creed and constitution of the Church in the hands of the Assembly. This court is invested with an authority similar to that claimed by the Pope in the church of Rome, so that it may add to or take from the doctrines of the Word of God. “The substance of the Faith” is therefore as large or as small as the Church, or the Assembly, chooses to make it. No one knows, therefore, how soon “the substance of the Faith” may vanish away altogether.

5. The Declaratory Act embodies in the Creed of the Church errors of an Arminian, Semi-Pelagian, un-Presbyterian, Voluntary, and Popish character.

This may seem a bold and incredible catalogue. Let anyone, however, apply himself to the examination of the above Act, and he will find that, if language has any meaning at all, these errors are there declared as the belief of the Church. The names we give may not appear, but the realities show themselves with little disguise. “The substance of the Faith” has been left undefined, but the errors accepted by the Church are not so dealt with. They are sufficiently well stated. In the acceptance of these errors “the substance of the Faith” has been practically lost.

6. The Church, embracing ministers, office-bearers, and the whole body of the people, is involved in the guilt and consequences of adopting this Act.

The General Assembly, it is true, declared that the Act was not binding on any particular person. Did that declaration make the Act any less the Church’s Act? Once the consent of the Church as a body was secured, there was no necessity to make every particular individual accept it. That individual had already accepted it in his Church capacity. If there were any persons that were prepared to act so inconsistently as to submit to one thing in their Church capacity which they in their private capacity disowned, then it would appear that the Church was cunning enough not to press them on this point. No one, therefore, was commanded to accept the Act by personal profession, so that objectors might rest with ease in the net in which they were caught. Some are inclined to think that the Act has only to do with office-bearers. But the office-bearers represent the people. The people are, therefore, equally involved. As a necessary consequence the people are now entitled by the law of this Church to hold the same views as the office-bearers in regard to the doctrines of the Act. What is right for the office-bearers to believe cannot be wrong for the people.

7. Persons may demand Baptism and the Lord’s Supper who accept Declaratory Act doctrines.

Those office-bearers who profess to adhere to the principles of 1843 and have inconsistently remained in the Free Church, cannot refuse these sacraments to believers in this Act. The latter are entitled to all Church privileges. If these privileges should be refused, an appeal to the Assembly would speedily settle the question.

8. Again, persons are not bound to accept any teaching from the pulpit beyond the views contained in this Act.

Ministers may preach the soundest Calvinism, but the ordinary or the occasional hearer has a perfect right to say to himself, “You may insist as you please, upon election, total depravity and such doctrines, but I am warranted by the authority of the whole Church to which you belong, yea, even by you, in your Church capacity, to believe quite different doctrines. I think that it is more likely the Church should be right, than any single individual minister; and more than that, what can I make of the preaching of a minister who, by the Creed of his Church declares one thing, while by his individual testimony declares quite another?” We see, therefore, that not only are private persons involved, willingly or unwillingly, in the guilt of this Act, but that all private persons whatsoever have a rightful liberty to accept no teaching whatsoever beyond that found in this Act. The serious effects such a state of matters may have on the minds of the people, especially of the young, it is sad to think of.

9. The body that has adopted this Act has evidently given away its testimony for the truth.

What legacy has it to leave to coming generations? A corrupt creed and an evacuated Bible. Take away the doctrines of grace from the Bible and there is nothing left but an empty shell. The Free Church has, however, not only taken away the kernel, it has practically thrown away the shell. The infallibility and inspiration of the Scriptures have been denied, and the Church has condoned the denial. Its testimony for the Word of God and the invaluable doctrines of grace has been cast into the devouring depths of godless criticism by unbelieving teachers whom the Church delights to honour.

10. The last consequence we shall meantime mention is that it has become the bounden duty of all who esteem the Word of God and the doctrines of the Gospel, to separate from a body which has so highly dishonoured Christ and injured the souls of men by its procedure.

The Lord hath said, “Have no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, but rather reprove them” (Ephesians 5:11). Many interpret this passage, “Have fellowship, and reprove”. But the Word clearly says, “Have no fellowship”, and the further exhortation plainly means, “but rather add to your lack of fellowship with these works, not silence, but reproof”.

Previous / Next

Upcoming Events

Jun 30
30 Jun - 4 Jul

Communion: Beauly

Jul 7
7 Jul - 11 Jul

Communions: Bonar Bridge, Staffin, Uig

Jul 12
All day

Meeting of Presbytery: Asia Pacific

Jul 14
14 Jul - 18 Jul

Communions: Shieldaig, Fort William

Jul 21
21 Jul - 25 Jul

Communions: Auckland, Struan

View Calendar

About Us

  • Who We Are
    • The Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland – Why It Exists Today
    • The Free Presbyterian Church Catechism
      • A Catechism of the History and Principles of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland – PDF
      • 1. Origins of the Free Presbyterian Church (1-13)
      • 2. The Westminster Confession of Faith (14–22)
      • 3. The Declaratory Act and the Free Church (23–53)
      • 4. The Infallibility of Scripture (54-67)
      • 5. Erroneous Doctrines (68-77)
      • 6. Innovations in Worship (78-93)
      • 7. Church and State (94-104)
      • 8. Church office-bearers (105-130)
      • 9. Church Courts (131-140)
      • 10. Church Unity (141-149)
      • 11. Modern Religious Cults (150-159)
      • 12. Modern Errors (160-170)
      • 13. Evolution (171-175)
      • 14. Christ’s Second Coming (176-179)
      • Appendix 1. Deed of Separation 1893
      • Appendix 2. Free Church of Scotland Declaratory Act 1892
      • Appendix 3. FP Synod Resolutions
      • Appendix 4. Questions put to Office-bearers and Formula to be signed by them
      • Appendix 5. Memorandum on the Church of Scotland Enabling Bill 1920
    • The Declaratory Act Controversy
      • Declaratory Act – Reasons for Separation
      • How the Declaratory Act changed the Constitution of the Free Church
      • Explanatory Criticism of the Declaratory Act
      • The Consequences of the Declaratory Act
      • The Declaratory Act and Admission into Office in the Free Church
      • The Constitutional Aspects of the Declaratory Act
      • A Brief History of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland
  • What We Contend For
    • Our Free Presbyterian Heritage
    • The Authorised Version
      • The Importance of the Authorised Version for the Church in Britain
      • 2015 Synod Resolution on Versions of the Bible
    • Evangelical or Reformed
    • A Protestant Witness
      • The Pope and the Constitution of the United Kingdom
      • The Pope as the Head of a False Religion
      • Papal Infallibility
      • The Pope in Scripture
    • The Five Points of Calvinism
      • The Canons of Dort
    • The Free Offer of the Gospel
    • Resolution on Creed Subscription
    • Church Discipline
      • The Purposes of Church Discipline
      • The Church’s responsibility to administer Biblical discipline faithfully
      • The benefits of exercising Church discipline
      • Accusations Levelled against a Church Exercising Discipline
    • Baptism
      • Subjects of Baptism – by Rev. William MacIntyre
      • Mode of Baptism – by Rev. William Macintyre
      • Should Infants be Baptised?
    • The Lord’s Supper
      • Why do the minister and elders interview intending communicants?
      • Restricted Communion
      • Fencing the Table
        • The Origins of Fencing the Table
    • Our Separate Stance
    • The Sabbath
      • Why the Sabbath should Still be Kept
      • How the Sabbath should be Kept
      • Sabbath or Lord’s Day – not “Sunday”
      • What about using Public Transport on the Sabbath?
        • Synod’s Statement in Reference to Church-going by Public Conveyances on the Sabbath
        • Historical Controversy over Using Public Transport on the Lord’s Day
    • Family worship
      • Family worship – a recent overview
      • Family worship – a recent address to young people
      • Family worship – a convicting appeal from C H Spurgeon
      • Family worship – a wartime appeal from more than a century ago
      • Family worship – a review
      • Family worship – another wartime appeal
      • Family worship – an illustration of its power
    • Distinctions between Male and Female
      • Men and Women Equal in Value
      • The Distinct Roles of Men and Women
      • Can women lead in public prayer?
      • Distinct Clothing for Men and Women
      • Long hair for women and short hair for men
        • If a Woman have Long Hair, it is a Glory to Her
  • What We Believe
  • How We Worship
    • Order of Service
    • The Right Way to Worship
      • Standing for Prayer
      • The Charismatic Movement – The Gifts have Ceased
    • The Regulative Principle of Worship
      • Does the Bible tell us how we are to Worship?
      • The Importance of the Regulative Principle for Today
      • The Regulative Principle as defined by the Scottish Reformers and others
    • Exclusive Psalmody
      • Does the Bible tell us What to Sing?
      • Why Psalms Only
    • No Musical Instruments
      • Musical Instruments in Worship
    • No Christian “Festivals”
      • Should Christians Celebrate Christmas?
  • How We Are Organised
    • Church Courts
    • Scripture does teach the right form of Church Government
    • The Apostolic Church – Which Is It?
      • Statement of the Question
      • Meaning of the word Church
      • Government of the Church
      • Apostolic Principles
      • The First Principle
      • The Second Principle
      • The Third Principle
      • The Fourth Principle
      • The Fifth Principle
      • The Sixth Principle
      • Application of the Test
      • Application of the Test to Prelacy
      • Application of the Test to Independency
      • Application of the Test to Presbytery
      • Application of the Test – Result
  • Important Documents
    • The Scots Confession
    • The First Book of Discipline
    • The Second Book of Discipline
    • The National Covenant
    • The Solemn League and Covenant
    • The Westminster Confession of Faith
    • The Larger Catechism
    • The Shorter Catechism
    • The Directory for Public Worship
    • The Form of Presbyterial Church Government
    • The Sum of Saving Knowledge
    • The Directory for Family Worship
    • The Claim Declaration and Protest
    • The Protest
    • The Deed of Separation 1893
  • Frequently Asked Questions

Latest Articles

  • Special Offers on New Books for June
  • May 2022 Magazines now available online
  • Synod Resolution re The Church of Scotland’s Declaration of Friendship with the Roman Catholic Church

Recently Added Audio

  • ‘Not silent in the night’ 12 Jun 2022
  • Christ a Priest for ever 19 Jun 2022
  • Sitting at the King’s table 19 Jun 2022
  • A prophecy of Christ as King entering Jerusalem. 12 Jun 2022
  • The parable of the talents (2) 12 Jun 2022
  • A provision for sinners 5 Jun 2022
  • The parable of the talents (1) 5 Jun 2022
  • A Shepherd for the straying sheep 6 Mar 2022
  • Under the Apple Tree 6 Mar 2022
  • Loved unto the end 20 Feb 2022

View All Sermons

Download Latest Issues:
The Free Presbyterian Magazine
Young People’s Magazine

Free Presbyterian Places of Worship

Browse the Church Bookshop

Special Offers on New Books This Month

Conversations with a Dying Man by Samuel Rutherford, £3.95

Old Paths by J C Ryle, £11.99

Mfundisi Tallach: A Man with a Burden for Souls by Catherine Tallach, £8.00

The Plain Mr Knox by Elizabeth Whitley, £6.39

Redemption: Accomplished and Applied by John Murray, £5.59

(Postage is extra.)
Available from the Free Presbyterian Bookoom.

Back to top

Website Contact

Rev Keith M Watkins
[email protected]

Moderator of Synod

Rev Donald A Ross
Free Presbyterian Manse
Laide
Ross-shire
IV22 2NB
[email protected]

Clerk of Synod

Rev Keith M Watkins
Free Presbyterian Manse, Ferry Road, Leverburgh, Isle of Harris, HS5 3UA, UK.
[email protected]

General Treasurer

Mr William Campbell
133 Woodlands Road, Glasgow,
G3 6LE, UK.
[email protected]

Copyright © 2022 Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland · Log in · Subscribe via RSS · Privacy Notice