Roman Catholic Doctrinal Controversy in Holland
Bitter controversy among Roman Catholic theologians in Holland has arisen over the publication of a Catechism by some who are described as progressive Dutch theologians. The purpose was to produce a catechism which explained points of Roman Catholic doctrine in a language which the ordinary Roman Catholic could understand. It was published in 1966, and thousands of copies have been sold in Europe and America. The Catechism was approved by the Dutch bishops and Cardinal Alfrink. Now the more “conservative” theologians in Holland are declaring that there is heresy in this publication; and they have submitted the matter to Rome, over the heads of their bishops; said to be an unprecedented step. The authorities in Rome are reported as wishing to rewrite most of the book. Two theologians from Rome have recently been in Holland to put their demands to the Dutch clergy involved. Some time ago, a Dutch friend explained to us that these “progressives” in the Dutch Roman Catholic Church, are not reformers at all in the light of Protestant doctrine and practice. They constitute a modernistic movement within the Church of Rome. The authority of Pope and Papal power seated at Rome, are apparently losing the absolute influence claimed for them. The unity said to prevail throughout the Church of Rome is being seriously disturbed, once and again in these times. We wonder how ecumenism is accepted in Holland, when controversy is rife in the ranks of Roman Catholics.
(It is regretted that owing to lack of space remaining Notes and Comments have been held over for the May issue).